MLB: 2026 AL Cy Young Winner

Traders currently price "Cam Schlittler" at 59% for "MLB: 2026 AL Cy Young Winner". Over the past 24 hours that probability moved down 3.0 points. Full distribution: Cam Schlittler 59%, Dylan Cease 35%, Drew Rasmussen 3%, Sonny Gray 1%. The market has traded $1.3M in total volume and resolves Nov 12, 2026. Cam Schlittler leads the 2026 AL Cy Young market as the Yankees right-hander posts an AL-best 2.21 ERA with strong innings totals, a sub-1.00 WHIP, and elite bWAR through late summer, reflecting consistent dominance that has kept him atop most voter polls. Dylan Cease trails closely at the Blue Jays, where his league-leading strikeout totals, superior FIP, and low hit/HR rates fuel a strong case despite fewer decisions and a midseason hamstring absence; recent dominant stretches have narrowed the gap in advanced metrics. Lower-priced names like Drew Rasmussen sit well back due to limited volume and less dominant rate stats compared with the top two. The tight Schlittler-Cease duel mirrors a season-long battle defined by ERA leadership versus strikeout and peripheral edges, with remaining starts and any late injuries likely to shape final voter consensus.

Odds sourced live from Polymarket, refreshed through the day. Prediction-market participation carries risk and may be restricted in your jurisdiction. Informational only — not investment advice.